Comments on: Eclipse by Stephenie Meyer

By: sabrina

sabrina — Fri, 01 Aug 2008 17:56:18 +0000

I love the Twilight series….Eclipse was fantastic and I hope Breaking Dawn will be just as good. I hear that BooksOnBoard is giving
away the Breaking Dawn ebook for free… I’ve already pre-ordered my
copy! I’m so excited about Breaking Dawn… I love Edward!!!!!

By: sevannah

sevannah — Tue, 08 Jul 2008 06:43:18 +0000

as for clairec23 the whole sneeking out thing is just because edward wants to protect her because he loves her so much.and people and bella thinks that he always wins but in actuallity he doesnt cuz if you think about it bella is the one whose always whining!!!and not to like call you out or anything im just trying to state facts!!!

By: JALP

JALP — Fri, 27 Jun 2008 16:01:04 +0000

I wonder how old most of you are that read and comment on this book…I’m guessing fairly young and probably still in high school. Well, let me give you my older and slightly more experienced point of view as some one who just graduated college.

I really liked Eclipse. I thought it was beautifully written and had a much more mature tone to the book. Yes I disliked how possessive Edward was but in the end he admitted to being jealous which, believe me, can make men do crazy things. But he is also very understanding and truly loves Bella. Their relationship to me is much more passionate and mature (Edward, after all, is like 90!)

I was suprised to see so many people cheering for Jacob and Bella because to me it just seems like an immature relationship. One that is fun and playful but that would seem to fade quickly. I found Jacob annoying and immature to a point where he didn’t seem attractive. It seems like the safer choice for Bella but could she really be with him for ever and not constantly remember and wish for the passion and undying love she had with Edward.

This is only my opinion so take it or leave it. If it were me I would want to be with Edward. Not only is he wonderfully caring, beautiful, and truly in love with Bella, but he also has a side that isn’t perfect and not so confident. It’s endearing. He would always love her and be understanding that’s why it’s so hard to see Bella be such immature girl. Oh well.

TEAM EDWARD!!

By: Sarah

Sarah — Wed, 18 Jun 2008 17:37:46 +0000

I just finished reading the 3rd book, eclipse. Could someone explain the end to me. I did not understand a thing in “Epilogue-choice”. I re read it a couple times and kept re interpreting it differently. If some one could enlighten me it would be greatly appreacated.

By: Balletgirl

Balletgirl — Fri, 30 May 2008 02:37:24 +0000

I have one thing to say for all of you Jacob lovers out there- YOU ARE CRAZY!! No offense or anything, but can’t u see that Bella and Edward belong together. I loved the ending of Eclipse, and I hope that Jacob stays away for good.

ALSO TEAM EDWARD!

By: Ximena

Ximena — Thu, 22 May 2008 20:57:32 +0000

I think Bella loves Jacob not Edwar. How could you love some one if you feel that you dont deserves him. Edwar is so handsome thats his only card. Bella is happy with Jacob but she is envolved by Edward charme.

By: maria

maria — Tue, 13 May 2008 17:49:38 +0000

i agree with alexa.

bella does not deserve edward after all hes done for her, its so hard for her to agree to marry him and she actually has trouble choosing between him and jacob. she even asked jacob to kiss her. NO SERIOUSLY JUST NO. thats not right. and edward is so understanding with her she doesnt deserve him. it seems to me like she even had to FORCE herself to be with edward. almost like she would rather be with the werewolf. i really hated the ending of this book. because im not sure anymore about bella and edward. i know they should be together but bella seems like shes unhappy with her choice. it seems like she’s doing what she thinks is right but not what makes her happy. if she loves edward so much then why does she have so many doubts?!?! shes so stupid. ughhh

and jacob needs to leave already. i understand where hes coming from but NO. he needs to just goo ugh. he made everything complicated. besides. both him and bella know that when he imprints, hes goign to have to leave bella. so if she chose jacob she would one day lose him. so idk why he insists on chasing after bella if shes not his soulmate. and i hate how bella almsot wishes edward wouldnt have came back. HFGH4FGEFGYUI i dont even know anymore, it ended on such a depressing note.

TEAM EDWARD
even if bella deserves jacob. stupid stupid stupid

By: Jean

Jean — Wed, 07 May 2008 06:48:34 +0000

I liked the book, well, the series to be more exact but I was a bit bothered by this third book as I felt that the Bella and Jacob connection is so much a cliche. Why not stick to just one guy, instead of forcing a love triangle into a perfectly good fantasy/love story?

By: Alicia

Alicia — Thu, 03 Apr 2008 05:52:45 +0000

I LOVED THE SERIES SO FAR!
but really dissapointed in the ending. i dont think there should be any kind of love connection between jacob and bella! it started out as them being best friends it should’ve stayed like that. and now it just seems like she’s forcing herself to be with edward.
I dont know i kind of got upset with that.

By: AMBER

AMBER — Sun, 23 Mar 2008 21:37:05 +0000

HEY OMG I LOVE ECLIPSE I REALLY WANT TO SEE IF BELLA REALLY GETS MARRIED TO EDWARD AND IF SHE BECOMES MORE POWERFUL THEN HIM? IN NEW MOON WHEN BELLA STARTED 2 GET CLOSE TO JACOB I STARTED TO GET MAD AT HER BECAUSE SHE WAS USING HIM AND I KINDA KNEW EDWARD WOULDNT LEAVE HER FOREVER AND WHEN HE WAS IN ITALY I THOUGHT HE WAS DIED I WAS SAD BUT I REALLY JUST HOPE JACOD MOVES ON